Randy Bishop
Usenet Archive
- Joined
- Jan 21, 2003
- Messages
- 10
- Reaction score
- 0
You know the story - just happened to us. Six hours from home, the tranny in our 2000 GV self destructed coming off the interstate. Took it to an indepenent ATRA shop & opted for a bench rebuild. Failure sequence appears to be : Torque converter > pump > everything else. Cost with an 18/18 nationwide warranty - $2400. Tranny was serviced at severe duty service interval. (73,000 on tranny at failure). Our 89 Caravan suffered a similar failure at about the same point in its life
Thinking about this experience led me to this idea which I would like to discuss.
DC uses the same tranny across a broad product line, in vehicles with wide ranging GVWR. In the lighter cars with limited seating and hauling capabilities, the tranny will hold up for the life of the vehicle. In the minivans, the loads are much higher and put more stress on the tranny, resulting in a shorter life.
After two experiences, I think if I purchase another van, I will go full size with conventional layout.
Has anyone done any research on vehicle size/weight vs. tranny failure rate?
Randy
Thinking about this experience led me to this idea which I would like to discuss.
DC uses the same tranny across a broad product line, in vehicles with wide ranging GVWR. In the lighter cars with limited seating and hauling capabilities, the tranny will hold up for the life of the vehicle. In the minivans, the loads are much higher and put more stress on the tranny, resulting in a shorter life.
After two experiences, I think if I purchase another van, I will go full size with conventional layout.
Has anyone done any research on vehicle size/weight vs. tranny failure rate?
Randy