"Howard" wrote:
Not sure, BUT!!!!!!!!!
I believe the dealership (or any service center for that matter) is
required
to get your agreement to do any job that goes over the original estimate
by
This is true but remember they haven't exceeded the 1600. All they did is take apart the engine and it's now in pieces. They can probably put it back together with the new timing belt for the $1600 and it's still going to be making the ticking noise. And she hasn't said that what amount they have decided to charge for it as of yet.
For the money involved an and no transportation, PERHAPS ( and I detest
the
need) consulting an attorney may be the cheapest way out of this.
No, that just is throwing more money after bad. She has to make a decision now, either stay with the dealership, or go elsewhere.
I'm going to assume that the dealership is looking at it from the point of view that here's this nice clean 3 year old car, probably low mileage, with a bad engine. They do not know what she spent on the thing, of course. So for a comparatively small $6K you get a vehicle that has a new engine (I'm assuming the $6K is for a factory new) and will probably last at least 100,000 miles. That is not a bad deal. Even adding in the $6K that she spent on it, $12K is still not a terrible deal.
Now of course, she is pissed off because she made the mistake that many used car buyers make - she shot her entire wad on the purchase price. Anyone who has bought used cars before knows that if you have a pot of $6000 to expend on a used car, that you save aside at least $1000 of it, preferably more, and buy a used vehicle in the $4000 range. Then when the inevitable problems develop you can fix them and get a good vehicle out of it.
But even so, buying a used car is a gamble. You are gambling that you can get a much lower cost-per-mile then the person that buys a brand new car. For example, the new car purchaser drops $30,000 on a new vehicle and drives it for 50,000 miles, then sells it for $15,000. His cost per mile is 50 cents a mile. You buy the car for $15,000 and drive it for 100,000 miles, then sell it for $2,000. You cost per mile is 13 cents a mile - if your lucky. If however you lose the gamble and have to spring $6K for a new engine, then your cost per mile jumps to 19 cents per mile. It's still better than the new vehicle - but it's an extra $6K that you were hoping to avoid paying.
She is choosing to take umbrage out on the dealership. But before things escalate, she needs to sit back and realize that she took a gamble and she lost. The seller of the vehicle won the game because he obviously never spent a dime on maintainence. It never feels good to be the loser - but if you do lose a gamble, the stupid thing is to compound the loss in a fit of pique.
At this point she owns a car worth scrap value, that she owes $6K on. She can take the $6K as a total loss and start the process all over again and gamble another $6K on another used vehicle, so she's now $12K in the hole, on another vehicle that has an unknown history. Or she can increase the $6K loss by a few thousand more by throwing money at an attourney and still have to start the process all over again.
Or she can convert the $6K loss into a $12K gamble on a vehicle that has a 3 year old body and an equivalent to a brand new engine. That's called stacking the deck in your favor. Espically if she gets a warranty on the rebuilt engine. If the body is straight and there's not a lot of mileage on the transmission, this is a perfect candidate for a rebuild. Many times good rebuilders make corrections on the original design, such as enlarging oil passages that are too small, using forged parts instead of cast, etc. You can end up with a better engine than what rolled off the assembly line.
Ultimately of course, she is still going to pay less than the new car purchaser. And if she can buy the new engine and drive the car until the $12K she has to finance for it is paid off, she probably will be OK with it.
Did you save/get paper work stating a timing belt? If there is no belt, perhaps this may be a good starting point to show inept procedures?
That won't do dick. Even if they are totally inept, her car is still got a busted engine. And it's kind of hard to argue that they broke something that is already broken.
Hopefully, she isn't a troll and posts a followup. We can help her here in asking the right questions and understanding what she can get in the new engine department.
Ted